2019 Elk Hunt
I don't know why I put in to draw for
elk this year. I have applied several times before when I was
younger and prompted to do so by my son and/or brother. Both were
avid hunters who passed away in 2016 and 2018 respectively. Perhaps
it was habit, or some prompting from beyond, either way I knew my
chances were slim. I didn't expect that with only eight preference
points I would draw a tag in one of the most coveted areas in
southern Utah. The Utah Division of Wildlife Resources allowed only
64 resident and 7 non-resident permits for the early season hunt on
the Plateau, Fishlake/Thousand Lakes unit that year. The hunt takes
place in mid September during the rut. Fifteen preference points
give one a good chance of securing a tag, but eight gives you
slightly over a 10% chance of success. Somehow I drew one of the two
tags issued to someone with only eight points.
As I planned and began to prepare, it
was with mixed feelings. Over the past 20 years my hunting and fishing companions had been my younger brother, Gary, and my eldest son,
Tony, and neither would be hunting with me this year. It was an
emotional time as I planned and scouted the area. Each trip to the
high country brought back so many memories. Memories of times spent
on earlier trips, hunting elk or deer, fishing Seven Mile creek, the
beaver ponds and Gates lake. In earlier times we would spend a week
or two camped on the Fishlake hightop, hunting elk or deer. We would
hunt morning and evening and play cards, nap or fish in the heat of
the day. On one trip I hunted in the morning with my oldest son,
Tony and Gary Simonson, a close friend. As the day wore on and the
elk bedded down in the thick timber we made our way to the beaver
ponds. It was one of those rare times when it didn't matter what you
threw in the water. We caught brook and cutthroat trout one after
the other until the cool of the evening breeze got the elk up from
their beds. My son was 14 years old and the memories we created are
memories that will last me forever. It was that memory and so many
more like it that would make this hunt an emotional roller-coaster.

I got a call from my brother-in-law
Dave. He asked what I was planning for the hunt and told me that he
and two of his sons, Chad and Jason, were planning on coming up and
joining me. They did not have tags but wanted to join in and provide
the hunting companions I was missing. Dave is a compassionate,
caring man who, with my sister Cathy, cared for my dying brother for
the last several months of his life. Chad and Jason are avid hunters
who have hunted in Africa and other areas of the world and would be
excellent companions who could add not only companionship, but
hunting expertise. Their offer was welcomed. Dave and Chad would
come up Friday evening and Jason would join us Sunday night. I talked
to each and was grateful for their offer to join me and for their
excitement in spending time together and enjoying the outdoors. They
were positive about our chances of success and repeatedly told me we
would find an elk to bring home.

I started by scouting the areas on the
hightop where I had hunted in the past. My first scouting trip was
to Neals Flat with Tony's two young sons, Tony and Sam. The high
mountains had been blessed this year with an abundance of moisture.
The meadow was painted in shades of white and lavender by blooming
Columbines. The wildflowers were stunning. We parked at the end of
the road and began the hike in to the flat. It started with a mild
uphill climb but the altitude took its toll on me and the young boys
who live on the coast of Texas at near sea level. Pacing ourselves
we worked our way to the tree line
. I was surprised by the lack of
elk sign as we continued to the upper meadow. The boys were excited
and it showed as they talked almost continuously as we hiked on. I
explained that talking would limit the number of animals we would see
and they quieted down until they saw a doe and fawn. The excitement
took over again and the continuous conversation began anew. The
excitement was heightened when they found a cow skull, bleached by
the weather and sun. Tony spotted it, Sam collected it and carried
it all the way back to the truck. It how hangs on the fence at the
ranch, a reminder of a scouting trip where the priorities changed
from scouting elk to enjoying time watching the excitement in the two
young boys as they discovered the wonders and beauty of the mountain
landscape.
I continued scouting during the next
few weeks, and was disappointed in the amount of sign and the elk I
was seeing. It wasn't until the fifth trip to the mountain that I
saw my first elk. We had scouted near Two Ponds, Brown's Hole and
Cold Springs without seeing or hearing anything. We were approaching
what should have been the start of the rut, but to date all was
quiet; the elk weren't talking. On our way off the mountain we
passed a truck parked along the side of the road, and Ian, Tony's 16
year old son, spotted the elk that the truck driver was looking at as
we passed. We stopped up the road and walked back to get a better
look. When the elk came into view there was a young four point bull
and a cow on the edge of the trees. Ian swore that he saw a bigger
bull as we drove past, but it had apparently gone
into the trees by
the time we got stopped. Still no bugling or cow talk.
The next day I continued the scout
hiking from the spot where we saw the elk the evening before to
Salina Reservoir, beautiful country, but no elk and still quiet. I
Checked around Farnsworth, and Harves reservoir and Two Ponds and
Cold Springs with similar results. The lack of elk sign and absence
of vocalization was beginning to concern me. I returned to Neals
Flat, hiked in and checked for sign. The absence of sign and the
eerie quiet failed to produce any assurance of success in the coming
hunt, now only three days away.

On the morning of the Thursday prior to
the hunt I set out early to scout new areas. I drove to Oak Ridge
and atop the high ridge at the end of the road I stopped and walked
to the east rim. All was quiet. The forest floor spread out below
me, covered with thick aspen, oak and brush. I sat listening and
nothing. I pulled the diaphragm call from my pocket and cow called.
Instantly I got an answer, a mild bugle. It was followed by a deep,
bellowing bugle from farther away. As I continued calling my calls
were responded to by no less than three bulls. One sounded
substantially larger than the others. My spirits were renewed.
Perhaps there was hope of seeing a bull in the coming days. I
decided to set up camp that afternoon at Cold Springs. The calls
were coming from Brown's Hole so I decided that would be the starting
point opening morning.
After setting up camp at Cold Springs,
that night I returned home. The plan was to return to camp Friday
afternoon after Ian got out of school, cook dinner and prepare for
the arrival of Dave and Chad. With my wife, Susanne's help, we
gathered the necessary food and supplies, I touched base with Dave
and his boys to let them know we were set up at Cold Springs and that
I would have dinner ready when they arrived. Friday afternoon Ian
and I headed to camp, set out the cooking equipment, the camp chairs
and got things ready to start dinner. We then went fishing at the
small pond at the end of the Cold Springs road, where we caught
several rainbow trout prior to starting dinner. The weather was warm
for the mountain in September, in the 60s. The leaves weren't
changing yet, but the shimmering of the green leaves on the aspen as
they reflected the evening sun in the cool evening breeze made me
glad I was taking the time to get away and enjoy nature's beauty.

Friday night we made the traditional
Dutch oven potatoes and added hamburgers to top off our pre-hunt
dinner. Dave and Chad arrived towing Jason's side-by-side. We got
set for the night and prepared for the morning's early start. As the
sun set a full moon rose over the eastern horizon. Its glow radiated
through the trees, casting eerie shadows around the camp. The bright
moonlight made me wonder what affect the increased visibility would
have on the behavior of the elk. Would they feed through the night?
If so, what impact wound that have on their behavior tomorrow? Would
they bed down at sun-up? We would see in the morning.
Five o'clock came early Saturday
morning. Ian decided he wanted to stay in camp and go fishing so he
slept in. Dave, Chad and I loaded into the side-by-side and headed
to Brown's Hole. We drove through the dark until we reached the lower
area of the valley and stopped the side-by-side. We sat in the dark
listening to the silence and the wind blowing through the trees
waiting for sunrise. Suddenly the quiet of the predawn was broken by
the sound of a bull elk's bugle. It sounded like a good bull located
some distance above us. My spirits soared knowing that we were at
least in one bull's terrain. Just before first light we got our
things together and began the stalk toward the last bugle. The
valley was thick with aspen, oak and brush. It made for a difficult
stalk as we moved forward stepping over dead fall trees with minimal
visibility through the brush. We went farther and the brush and
trees became more dense. Over the next rise, I thought, maybe it
will open up. It didn't. We heard a single gun shot, and Chad
struck out to see if he could find an opening in the brush. He did
and saw a cow and six point bull moving through the brush away from
the shot. They were heading our direction and his hope was that we
would get a shot but they never came into view. We moved to the
opening Chad had found and watched the hill across the ravine where
the elk had run. Nothing else was moving so we decided to take the
side-by-side and try to get in front of the elk. Our strategy didn't
work.
Later in the afternoon we returned to
Oak Ridge, above Brown's Hole. We called from the ridge and got an
answer from below. Again the brush and trees were dense and
visibility was limited. We walked the Oak Ridge Trail and listened,
trying to pinpoint the location of the bull. He was well down the
draw in the valley, the day was wearing on and after careful
consideration we opted to call it good for the morning. We headed
back to camp and had lunch. Ian wasn't there. When I checked he was
still at the pond and was successfully fishing having caught several
rainbow trout.
That evening we went back to Brown's
Hole and decided to hike in on the opposite side of the draw we had
been on in the morning, the side where Chad had seen the elk. The
evening was beautiful but the wind was swirling. We hiked in to the
area below where we had heard the bull from Oak Ridge. Nothing was
moving or talking. Just before sunset we headed out cow calling
periodically as we went. Half way back to the side-by-side an elk
began to bugle. He stopped halfway through the bugle and we couldn't
get him to respond back to us. As we made our way back, coming out,
we spotted a couple of hunters hiking in. Likely they got too close
and the bull quieted and noiselessly made his way away from us and
them.
I left Saturday night after dinner to
take Ian home so he could make school Monday. My plan was to get him
home, attend church and return early Sunday afternoon. We paused on
the way home repeatedly and listened for any elk sounds. All was
quiet. The moon was full making it easy to see along the way. We
didn't even see deer on the drive, which is quite unusual. We
arrived home safe, while Dave and Chad stayed in camp, spending some
dad and son time together.
When I arrived at camp on Sunday
afternoon our prospects were looking up. Chad had texted me that the
elk talk had increased and that they had heard elk in several
locations near camp. As the evening sun dropped low in the sky we
climbed the hill above camp, binoculars and spotting scopes in hand.
We hadn't been there long when the first elk bugled from across
Nioche Creek. As we sat and listened there were at least two larger
bulls and several smaller ones along the ridge. The larger bulls
seemed to be separated by about a mile, one right across from camp
and the second further to the south. The deep tone and distinct
growl lead us to believe they were worth pursuing. We listened and
glassed the area. A lone cow came to water in the creek and a single
5 by 5 bull worked down by the creek through the timbers. As we
discussed the plan for tomorrow we decided that in order to have a
chance at seeing one of the bigger bulls we would have to go where
they were. We would pack lunch, hike into the area from the bench to
the north of the ridge and spend the day, hoping the wind would be in
our favor and that the bulls would continue bugling in the morning.
Jason arrived at camp and joined us on the hilltop. It was his
birthday and Dave and Chad had picked up a cake in Richfield. We
celebrated, got prepped for the morning and turned in.
The anticipation was high as we got up
and moving. Old bones can take some time to get rattling before
sunrise, but we were parked and headed to the north bench just as
light was beginning to illuminate the terrain around us. As we moved
toward the creek the silence was broken by a bugle. It was followed
by another. We stopped and listened as bugles continued to echo from
the very ridge we had decided to hunt as we listened to the elk the
night before. Then a big, deep growling bugle came from the ridge.
We looked at each other, acknowledging that he sounded like a big
one. We worked our way across the bench and once on top headed
toward the elk. He continued to bugle periodically as we hiked
along. Once on the bench , the wind which was supposed to be blowing
consistently from the south, began changing direction, first one way
then another. The sky was overcast and sunlight filtered through
only for short periods of time. We continued working toward the
sound of the elk but it seemed that each time we crested a rise, he
was bugling just over the next rise. One rise after another, the
same scenario repeated itself, until we decided to take a break, have
lunch and see if the wind would settle down. We dumped our packs,
crashed out on the forest floor and waited.
If you have never laid down on the
forest floor you might think it comfortable. It's usually not. It
seems that you remove one stick or rock only to find another just in
the small of your back, hip or some other uncomfortable location.
With the overcast the ground was cold. Rest didn't come easy. The
cold can filter through multiple layers of clothing, packs and even
sleeping bags quicker than you would think, transferring the heat of
one's body into the cold earth. I tossed and turned, moved
locations, moved debris, all to no avail. I just couldn't get
comfortable. I suspect the others were similarly affected because it
only took about 40 minutes and we were ready to get moving.
The wind had shifted, coming down hill
so we decided to go up. We had barely gone 300 yards when the elk
bugled again. We pressed on in the direction of the sound and again
the loud, growling bellow broke the silence. This time we seemed to
be closing the gap. Dave and Jason decided that it would be best for them to hang back to lessen the noise and give Chad and I a better chance of getting close enough for a shot. Chad and I talked and decided to try cow
calling, to see if we would get a response. Chad sat just left of
the game trail we were on and I put my back against a tree to the
right and forward about 5 feet. Jason and Dave were behind us on the game trail standing separately and watching. Chad let out a chirp, nothing. We
waited and called again and waited. Eventually we heard a single cow
call. We discussed whether to challenge the bull with a bugle,
instead Chad cow called again. As we sat waiting, Chad whispered
there's a cow. I couldn't see her. “She's by the Christmas tree”
He was referring to a large fir tree in the midst of all the aspen.
I still couldn't see her. As she walked past the tree she came into
view, but if she had been a bull, I wouldn't have had a shot due the
density of the trees. “There's a calf” Chad said. He could see
a calf following the cow. I couldn't see it yet. Then excitedly,
Chad announced “He's coming in.” “I can't see him” I
whispered. “He's by the Christmas tree. He's Big” I didn't
dare move too much, but I slid slightly to the right and leaned to
that side. I still couldn't see him, but I could see the cow and
calf through an opening in the aspen about 100 yards away. “He's
following the cow” Chad reported, and just as he did the cow and
calf moved off and the bull stepped into the opening. I shot and he
humped up. I was pretty sure I had hit him in the chest, low near
the shoulder. Then I though “You have a semi auto.” I was
hunting with my old .30-06 Belgium made Browning Automatic Rifle. I
squeezed off another shot and he humped up again. My third shot
dropped him where he stood. Chad jumped up shouting, Dave and Jason
joined him and it was high fives all around.

When we got to him I was in awe at his
size. He was a typical 6 by 6 with a slight wave in one antler.
Until that moment he was a survivor. As we approached I noticed a
wound high on his back. It was a shallow puncture which lined up
with one of the points on his rack. It was obvious that he had been
fighting and another bull had turned his head far enough to drive the
point into his upper back.
After photos were taken, I commented on
how much my brother Gary would have enjoyed this moment stating “I
wish he could have been here” It was then that Dave responded, “He
is here.” He then told us that while he and Jason were back trail, he was standing alone leaning on a tree. He said he felt sharp
taps on his shoulder. They were distinct enough that he turned to
see which who had snuck up on him and touched him on the shoulder, but no one was there. After realizing where we all were he got the clear impression that Gary was
there and was letting him know he was with us. Gary would have let
Dave know if he were around before he would have let the rest of us
know. Dave provided end of life care for Gary and the two became
very close. No one would have enjoyed our success more than my
brother. As the elk was approaching Dave could not see it and did not know if we would get a clear shot so in his thoughts he was encouraging Gary to push the elk our way. He heard my first shot and wondered if his encouragement to Gary had worked. When I fired follow-up shots and he saw the downed elk, he was sure Gary had pushed the elk to me.
When we skinned the elk there was
another puncture wound on the opposite side of his back. The wound
channel was about 3/8” in diameter and about 14” long. It went
through and through his back strap and had healed. There was
another puncture near his shoulder on the side opposite to my shots.
I wondered if it was an exit wound but it was rather small, perhaps a
fragment. I stuck my finger in the wound to see if it penetrated and
found a broadhead embedded in his shoulder. He was a survivor, at
least until he walked into us. We dressed and quartered him and I
packed his head and rack, while Chad and Jason each took quarters and
Dave carried packs and my gun. We made it back to camp around 4:00
and caused quite a stir. After stopping at camp we were immediately
set upon by several hunters in side-by-sides. The questions flew for
several minutes. “Where did you get him”, “Is that the bull
from this place or that place.” “How many preference points did
you have to draw this hunt” When they left Dave commented that
they too might be successful if only they would leave the seats of
their side-by-sides to hunt. During the hunt we had seen several
hunters seated in their vehicles watching a hillside and while we
were stalking the elk we could hear the almost continuous drone of
side-by-sides running the roads and trails. Chad and Jason hiked back
in for the other quarters and were back in camp by 6:00. I
volunteered to help but they let me know that I would only slow them
down. Their youth and energy was greatly appreciated. I was beat.
If there is one thing I learned on this
hunt is that to see big elk, you need to go where they are and be
persistent. Fortunately on this early hunt, they were talking, and
talking loud and often. That allowed us to know we were working an
area where our chances of success we better than average. It let us
continue to follow the sound until we were fortunate enough to see a
big bull and get a shot at him. The value of family was reinforced
as Dave, Chad and Jason took time out of their days, shared
equipment, and expertise to help me complete a successful hunt. I
think they knew I was struggling with the emotional impact of loosing
my two hunting companions. I had been riding an emotional
roller-coaster loving the opportunity to hunt but fighting memories
of past hunts. Their help made this adventure possible and I will be
forever indebted to them for their sacrifice on my behalf. One
bucket list item down, hopefully, more to come.